• Ever Since Eve - 1943
• Once and For All - 1944
• The Christmas Carol Stars - 1948
• Divine Flora - 1949
• Meet Me in St. Louis - 1950
• Seventeenth Summer - 1951
• Mr. Barry's Etchings - 1951
• The Case of the Silent Caroler - 1951
• Our Miss Brooks - 1952
• No Room for a King - 1952
• At the Feet of the Madonna - 1953
• Men Are Like Street Cars - 1954
• Breen Valley - 1955
• Who Stayed Home? - 1955
• Curtain Going Up - 1956
• The Remarkable Incident at Carson Corners - 1957
• The Family Nobody Wanted - 1958
• Love Your Neighbor - 1959
• Rebel Without a Cause - 1960
• On With the Show - 1960
• The Thread That Runs So True - 1961
• Bye Bye Birdie - 1963

1964 - Actual Academy Players Drama Club Began

• Finian's Rainbow - 1965
• Love Makes the World Go Square - 1966
• The First Mrs. Paris - 1967
• Music Man - 1968
• The Miracle Worker - 1969
• Oklahoma! - 1970
• Under Milkwood - 1970
• Little Wormen - 1971
• Spoon River - 1971
• The Crucible - 1972
• The Cave Dwellers - 1972
• Hello Out There - 1972
• Camelot - 1973
• The Rimers of Eldritch - 1973
• Cactus Flowers - 1974
• Murder Takes the Stage - 1975
• The Night Thoreau Spent in Jail - 1975
• Petey's Choice - 1976
• You Can't Take it With You - 1976
• Our Town - 1977
• What's Wrong with the Girls - 1978
• Don't Drink the Water - 1978
• The Simple Truth - 1978
• The Braggart - 1978
• Ten Little Indians - 1980
• The Night Thoreau Spent in Jail - 1981
• Bye Bye Birdie - 1985
• I Know I Saw Gypsies - 1987
• Godspell - 1987
• Bye Bye Birdie - 1988
• The Face on the Barroom Floor - 1988
• You're a Good Man Charlie Brown - 1989
• Once Upon a Mattress - 1990

All Productions from 1991 - present were produced and directed by Mr. Scott Schauman. Musical Direction by Mrs. Mary Hamlin 1991 - 1999

• Damn Yankees - 1991
• The Mouse That Roared
• The Mystery of Edwin Drood - 1992
• Dark of the Moon - 1992
• Grease - 1993
• Kiss and Tell - 1993
• Fiddler on the Roof - 1994
• The Crucible - 1994
• Oklahoma! - 1995
• The Good Doctor - 1995
• West Side Story - 1996
• Death of a Salesman - 1996
• Into the Woods - 1997
• 3 "Plays in a Round": The Real Inspector Hound, Fool's Paradise, The Still Alarm - 1997
• Anything Goes - 1998
• Harvey - 1998
• Oliver! - 1999
• Our Town - 1999

Musical Direction by Jennifer Maxfield 2000-2001

• George M! - 2000
• Noises Off - 2000
• The Boyfriend - 2001
• Witness for the Prosecution - 2001

Musical Direction by Mrs. Amy Story 2002-2014

• Titanic - 2002
• The Man Who Came to Dinner - 2002
• Les Miserables - 2003
• Picnic - 2003
• Big River - 2004
• On the Tazzle - 2004
• Seussical - The Musical - 2005
• The Miser - 2005
• The Music Man - 2006
• Flowers for Algernon - 2006
• Beauty and the Beast - 2007
• You Can't Take It With You - 2007
• Ragtime - 2008
• Look Homeward, Angel - 2008
• Showboat - 2009
• The Phantom Tollbooth - 2009
• Les Miserables - 2010
• Detective Story - 2010
• Thoroughly Modern Millie - 2011
• The Crucible - 2011
• All Shook Up - 2012
• Battle of Angels - 2012
• Legally Blonde - 2013
• Rehearsal for Murder - 2013
• Titanic - 2014
• The Divine Flora - 2014

Musical Direction by Ms. Jenny Cerne 2015-Present

• Nice Work If You Can Get It - 2015
• Jabberwock - 2015
• The Little Mermaid - 2016
• Rimers of Eldritch - 2016
• Disaster! - 2017
• George Washington Slept Here! - 2017
• Ragtime-2018
• On the Razzle- 2018
• All Shook Up- 2019